I'm tempted to start my own index: the 'Bitcoin Badnews Ratio' [BBR], a contrarian signal. Let's see what happens in April. If the price trend is up, the BBR might actually have some merit.
I qualified the April trend in the '2018-04 Price' post as 'steady upward'. Since the March stories were overwhelmingly negative, the BBR's first test was in its favor. One sample does not confirm a theory and I'll come back to the idea later in this post.
The subject of gender equality is a hot topic these days, so it's no surprise that it has come up in the crypto world. Consider these two stories:-
- 2018-03-31: Bitcoin's Biggest Winners -- or Losers -- Are Likely to Be Men (theatlantic.com) 'Simply put, many more men are buying crypto than women. The combined market capitalization of all the currencies appears to exceed 300 billion dollars. And due to their greater participation in this extremely volatile and thus highly risky realm, men will likely wind up squandering hundreds of billions of dollars more than women -- or else, perhaps, enjoying hundreds of billions in additional wealth.'
- 2018-04-27: Bitcoin: Women Could Send Bitcoin Price to the Moon (fortune.com) 'One analysis of Google searches found that 95% of people Googling "Bitcoin" were male, while only 5% were female. The trend seems to carry across to other cryptocurrencies such as Ethereum: According to another recent survey, just 4% of Ethereum traders are women.'
The subject of taxes is always a hot topic in April, at least in the U.S. I counted as many stories in April as in the three previous months combined. For example:-
- 2018-04-14: Bitcoin's Rebound Could Continue After April 17 (forbes.com) Two points: 'How large could the tax liability be?' and 'Impact on Bitcoin could be substantial or minimal' (or something in between?).
- 2018-04-16: Looming tax deadline could be moment of truth for bitcoin bulls (marketwatch.com) 'Digital currency owners who made money in 2017 are having to convert crypto into fiat money to pay their taxes.'
Back to the BBR, if you took this title at face value, you would say the story was negative:-
- 2018-04-24: Let’s destroy Bitcoin (technologyreview.com; MIT) 'Three ways Bitcoin could be brought down, co-opted, or made irrelevant.'
The three ways are not imminent; they are hypothetical:-
'Option one: Government takeover'
'Option two: Facebook sneak attack' ['If Facebook could persuade a large enough fraction of Bitcoin users and miners to run its own proprietary version of the Bitcoin software, the company would thereafter control the rules.']
'Option three: Go forth and multiply' ['The trend among blockchain startups is to build services that function only with the use of a native cryptocurrency, one specifically designed for the application.']
That story was one in an issue of the 'MIT Technology Review' focused on the underlying technology: The blockchain issue (ditto; May/June 2018). I've bookmarked it for future review.
Looking at other stories for April, I saw a mixture of positive and negative angles. How to determine the trend? Let's compare the most positive of the positive stories against the most negative of the negative.
- 2018-04-17: Bitcoin boosted by IMF chief Christine Lagarde’s praise (marketwatch.com)
- 2018-04-25: ‘Bitcoin’ was the 9th most read article on Wikipedia in 2017 (thenextweb.com)
- 2018-04-28: St. Louis Federal Reserve Says Bitcoin Is “Like Regular Currency” (fortune.com)
I hope it's obvious that those were the positive stories. Here are the negative stories.
- 2018-04-13: How bitcoin and cryptocurrencies are fueling America's opioid crisis (cnbc.com) 'Drug dealers are using bitcoin to finance the deadly wave of fentanyl flooding into the country from overseas.'
- 2018-04-20: Bitcoin Mining Even Less Economically Viable Than Thought (fortune.com)
- 2018-04-24: Bitcoin is the greatest scam in history (recode.net) 'It’s a colossal pump-and-dump scheme, the likes of which the world has never seen.'
For me, the positive stories are less compelling than the negative. Of the other ~20 stories on my short list, only a half-dozen were positive or neutral, while the others were clearly negative. Here's one that would have made the 'most negative' list if I didn't want to go a little deeper:-
- 2018-04-28: 4 Key Reasons Why It's Time to Sell Bitcoin (thestreet.com)
The four key reasons are:-
'The Group Mentality Risk'
'Regulatory Risk'
'Slower Speed' ['Each person left 'holding the bag' is looking for a chance to dump the product.']
'Not the Only Game in Town'
All in all, the consensus sentiment in April was negative. If the BBR has any merit, May should be a good month. Since I'm writing this mid-month, I can already observe that it's not looking like a good month at all.
No comments:
Post a Comment